Psychologists have long known that women find it less difficult than men to switch between tasks. But how exactly their brains function differently in such situations has so far been unclear.
Recent research shows that male brains appear to consume more energy when they need to shift attention. Not only that, but for men there is greater activity in the dorsolateral prefrontal areas of the brain compared to women, as well as activation in some other areas which is not usually observed in women.
Such differences are typical of younger men and women aged 20 to 45, according to findings from experiments conducted by researchers at the Russian National Research University Higher School of Economics with collaborators.
Bilateral Brain Activation
Regardless of gender and age, task switching always involves activation in certain areas of the brain, particularly bilateral activation of the dorsolateral prefrontal areas, inferior parietal lobes and inferior occipital gyrus.
However, experiments conducted by S.V. Kuptsova, M.V. Ivanova, and others demonstrate that in women, task switching appears to require less brain power compared to men, who showed greater activation in the dorsolateral prefrontal areas as well as the involvement of supplementary motor areas and insula, which was not observed in women.
“We know that stronger activation and involvement of supplementary areas of the brain are normally observed in subjects faced with complex tasks. Our findings suggest that women might find it easier than men to switch attention and their brains do not need to mobilise extra resources in doing so, as opposed to male brains,”
explained pysychologist Svetlana Kuptsova of the Center for Speech Pathology and Neurorehabilitation, Moscow
Task Switching Tests
The experiments involved 140 healthy volunteers, including 69 men and 71 women aged between 20 and 65. The subjects were asked to perform a variety of tasks.
In one of the experiments using functional MRI, they were asked to perform a test that required switching attention between sorting objects according to shape (round or square) and number (one or two), in a pseudo-random order. Additionally, neuropsychological tests were conducted, including the D-KEFS Trail Making Test to measure the subjects’ ability to switch attention and the Wechsler Memory Scale test to measure their audial and visual memory.
The use of functional MRI allowed the researchers not only to observe the subjects’ behavior, but also to see what was going on in the brain as subjects switched between tasks and detect differences in brain activation between men and women.
The researchers found that the gender differences in the extent of brain activation when switching between tasks only occurred in subjects younger than 45 to 50, while those aged 50 and older showed no gender differences either in brain activation or speed of task switching.
According to the researchers, older men and women, starting at the age of 45 in women and 55 in men, experienced both increased activation of key areas involved and mobilisation of additional brain resources.
Brain Gender Mystery
The study confirmed that young women tend to cope with attention switching better than young men. While the reaction time is demonstrably different, according to Kuptsova, it is barely noticeable in everyday life, except perhaps that “it might make a difference in really stressful circumstances or in critical situations which require frequent switching of attention.”
However, science cannot currently explain the exact reasons for this difference. Any assumptions as to adaptive necessity are only speculation, Kuptsova argues.
For example, there is a popular hypothesis by American psychologist Jerre Levy as to why men tend to have better spatial skills while women are often better at more verbal tasks. According to Levy, these differences are caused by both evolutionary and social factors.
In ancient times, men spent their time hunting, which required good spatial abilities, while women were caring for children and thus needed good communication skills. In the course of evolution, these survival skills have been passed down to future generations.
“We could continue with the same logic and assume that homemaking and caring for children historically required women to be good at multitasking, but there is no hard evidence to support this theory,” Kuptsova concludes.
S. V. Kuptsova, M. V. IvanovaA. G. PetrushevskiyO. N. FedinaL. A. Zhavoronkova
Sex- and age-related characteristics of brain functioning during task switching (fMRI study)
Hum Physiol (2016) 42: 361. doi:10.1134/S0362119716040101